It seems no public figure can die now and be objectively criticized in the media, because we are all so hungry for primetime coverage of that Diana moment. I wonder if Elton John will rework a version of “Where to now St. Peter?” for the Papal Finale?
The connection to an old rocker would be apropos. JP2 was sort of the high-priced oldie rock band reunion tour of popes. The people paying for the high-priced tickets don’t really live that rockin’ believer lifestyle anymore, but they want to cling on to the time when they did. American Catholics, the richest in the world, have the most liberal lifestyles of religious folk in the US. The Church conveniently looks the other way.
Looks the other way while tremendous effort and resource is applied to “the JP2 phenomena”: development of “The Stadium Mass” and “The PopeMobile” (an armored car to get him closer to the people, think about it).

We are told that JP2 personally arranged for his death to be announced by automated email and SMS distribution to thousands.
All this is popstar stuff, not efforts or innovations in the spirituality of the church. Sure, JP2 was a nice looking old grandfatherly type of fella, but that too is part of being a popular icon. Reagan was one of those nice old guys who looked good on TV, and his passing was similarly cloying. I’m afraid the real legacies of these two men are those of similarly dire effects on real people.
While JP2 was on TV and in stadiums worldwide, looking so good in funny hats, his church was condemning the use of condoms to their unprecidented numbers of converts in the third world, where AIDS has become the most lethal epidemic of modern times. JP2’s Catholic Church was revealed to have aided and abetted a child abuse tragedy of Biblical scale. Yet The Church has used the sleaziest of corporate tactics to hide assets from the victims; those spiritually damaged people seeking the only measure of justice their painfully real world can possibly provide.
All of this went on while JP2 was Pope. And with all his god-granted power, he did nothing to stop it.
It’s sad when anybody dies. And I don’t believe JP2 was a monster. I do believe he was a symbol of a disease of our time, our preference for form over substance. And I do believe he was negligent. As I’m afraid we all are.